INDUCTION COOKING vs GAS… pros and cons.
My last kitchen post was titled induction cooking is magic… because I have been living under a rock.
Apparently.
Rock-dwelling-embarrassment aside, once I SAW induction? I was like– ok, well CLEARLY we can THROW EVERYTHING ELSE IN THE TRASH… right?
But first I asked YOU… because after all, I live under a rock, so possibly am not a good judge of non-rock technology.
If you are trying to decide for yourself whether induction is your jam, go read over 100 comments… (some about making jam!) They will tell you EVERYTHING YOU DIDN’T KNOW YOU NEEDED TO KNOW ABOUT INDUCTION COOKING.
But first we must address this:
WHERE IS THE FANCY?
There are standards to which I will be held to by the community.
And.
Um.
The community was NOT IMPRESSED.
Many people felt that induction was visually too “modern”… and were SURPRISED I’d even consider it.
IN MY DEFENSE:
To me, an induction cooktop has the potential to be more like NOTHING, than like modern… and for me, I would like to have NO kitchen items in my kitchen… “traditional” or not.
In my mind, having less “kitchen” will leave more room for “what in the name of all that is holy is that massive thing that does not fit in this house?”
I want people to come into my kitchen and be CONFUSED about what room they are in.
The stove just gives it away.
I’ll start with the induction CONS; to avoid irritating those of you who sit on the gas-range-endorsement-council.
If you live in a place where power failures are part of life, GAS IS YOUR FRIEND (although possibly, not your eyelashes’ friend.)
We put in both induction and gas when we renovated our kitchen. Mostly because where we live, power failures are a thing… I had visions of using both but the induction is so much better to cook on that we only use the gas when the power is out. If I could only have one I would take induction every day just for the ease of use, regardless of aesthetics.
Next, we have the Drama Queens… and as someone with a collection of tiaras, I afford them the respect owed their elevated status.
These people enjoy the experience of an iron rangetop– whacking the pots around while singing Rigoletto and dousing grease fires!
You LIKE smashing down saucepans and captaining your ship without concern for wussy glass surfaces… essentially, you LIKE THE FIRE.
I can get down with that.
Brava!
Then there are the romantics:
Ease of cleaning and the sleek look can’t overcome the joy of slowly stirring risotto over an open flame.
I am someone who once walked away from the stove, forgot about the stove, and did not remember it until Paul came running into the house shouting something about fire… and to be TOTALLY FAIR TO ME NOTHING WAS ON FIRE IT JUST SEEMED THAT WAY BECAUSE OF THE SMOKE.
But also to be fair to Paul, this has happened more than once.
Romantic!
My problem is that the stove is so boring… I hate cooking… I mean, I do it endlessly; but only because more than hating cooking, I hate eating food that other people have touched.
And also because I need Paul to live until he is 118.
Basically, I cook so that Paul is forced to accompany me to my grave… I have no idea what horrible thing he did in a previous life, but it must have been really bad.
You are not WRONG that I would enjoy a kitchen full of a giant enameled old stove and fancy brass hardware… so long as it came with a maid to clean it; because now that I know I have an option, I will never scrub a cooktop nook again.
Also, let us not forget that I wrote an entire manifesto about my pure HATRED of range hoods.
For me to have a BIG GAS RANGE… I’d need a BIGGER HOOD; capturing and remove those toxins is a system that comes with a HEFTY price tag… AND AS DISCLOSED: WE ARE POORS.
And as a poor, I struggle to spend huge wads of cash on SOMETHING I HATE.
I also struggle to write anything helpful about CFM’s, BTU’s, AIR RECOVERY, EXTRACTOR POWER, or how your hood is supposed to be larger than your range… BECAUSE NONE OF THAT IS HAPPENING AT MY HOUSE.
The other factor I was hopped up about, was having a WHITE induction, and having it INSET… and you talked me out of both.
So many of you sounded the discoloration alarm that I was forced to heed it… UNLESS someone shows up later and says— the new ones resist degradation and will stay white.
So I am back to DIY-slate counter tops and a black cooktop.
Theoretically.
In other insane and exciting news, we’ve chosen a fridge.
Other FYI, I am compelled to pass on: my bff told me that she has been reading that ESSENTIAL OILS ARE BAD FOR PETS… I haven’t researched, but Lara is super brain person, so if she says she is concerned, I am too!
Suzanne
March 9, 2018 @ 3:45 pm
Of course, back in the day the kitchen was a whole separate building, because who wants any of that mess/fire hazard inside your actual house? I say we go back to building outbuilding kitchens.
Nicole
March 12, 2018 @ 8:27 am
I am so glad that you changed your mind about the white- I live in France where I have seen the white induction cooktops turn disgusting yellow/beige, and while I didn’t think a comment would change your mind, I couldn’t imagine how you would be able to live with that. I have a regular induction cooker but I love the look of a big gas La Cornue and spent a difficult few weeks trying to decide if it was worth the $$$ to buy the La Cornue with induction cooktop. FInally, decided against it but I was sad to say good bye to perfection and settle. My husband and bank account were happier
Patricia
March 12, 2018 @ 11:59 am
My solution for induction was to keep them as hobs. I had room for an 80″ cooktop. I had it built 4″ lower than normal to make up for the height of the hobs. I designed the countertop to be in stainless with 3 coved side backsplash. Clean up is a piece of cake. Under the cooktop are four rows of drawers with four drawer deep. The drawers keep some cookware, dinnerware so I can plate at the cooktop and staples such as onions and potatoes. The drawers have cutouts, no hardware. Again no crevices for gunk to build up. Unconventional I know, but at almost 69, I could give a fiddly fig what other people think. So glad my house doesn’t have that gas smell or my cookware with the fired on crud on them.Do what makes your heart happy and don’t forget to feed Paul.
Amy
March 19, 2018 @ 9:32 am
As someone who doesn’t care how the food gets in her mouth as long as it does I have no option on cooktops but I would like to ask if you have any good, reliable sources or articles on pets vs essential oils. I’ve been diffusing oils for over a year and my dog/life partner/best friend (oh, also my boyfriend) sleep with me. So I need to know but have found a lot of confusing and contradictory information. Please pass it along! Thanks!
Christina
August 2, 2020 @ 6:51 pm
I hope you opted for the induction countertop sorcery. Waiting patiently, not so much, to see how Amazing it turns out.
Laurie Olson
April 22, 2022 @ 8:56 pm
I have had induction for 14 years. Married to an HVAC contractor (41 years) who says absolutely no open flame cooking in an area where we plan to continue to breathe. We are building a new house, with our dream kitchen, and again we are having induction. We were told the only thing that can stay in the glass is boiling over something with sugar in it and not wiping it up right away, and I really embrace that idea so we have no staining. I did chip one because I dropped a vinegar bottle (glass) on the edge. The chip was large, but not large enough to dissuade me from having induction. The ease of cleaning and the fact that it nearly disappears in my kitchen are worth it. Plus after this many years I know how to cook with it and I am content.